Sunday, March 26, 2023

The place Ought to You Promote Your Automotive?

DollarBreak is reader-supported, once you join by hyperlinks on this submit, we could obtain compensation. Disclosure.

The content material is for informational functions solely. Conduct your personal analysis and search recommendation of a licensed monetary advisor. Terms.

Which is Higher for Promoting the Automotive?

Promoting your automotive with Shift and CarMax is an analogous expertise in some ways. Each corporations give you a free on-line quote and provide you with 7 days to think about your supply. With each corporations, you may promote your automotive and obtain your cost inside 24 hours.

Nonetheless, there are some variations that set these two corporations aside. 

General, Shift is the higher car-buying company to promote your automotive to. Shift provides free pick-up to your automotive and provides to pay you by a direct financial institution switch whereas CarMax pays you with a financial institution draft that may take 1-4 days to indicate up in your checking account. Shift additionally has a lot increased buyer scores and critiques compared to CarMax.

Shift Abstract

  • Fast 24 hour cost processing time
  • Further $200 bonus for promoting your automotive
  • 2 choices for evaluating your automotive
  • As much as 7 days to think about Shift’s supply

CarMax Abstract

  • On the spot on-line supply in beneath 2 minutes
  • On-line supply is legitimate for as much as 7 days
  • 2 choices for promoting – on-line or in-store
  • Receives a commission inside half-hour on the spot

Shift vs. CarMax Comparability

Shift CarMax
Vehicles accepted Used and new automobiles Used and new automobiles
Charges No charges No charges
Requesting quotes In-person and on-line software In-person and on-line software
Supply validity 7 days 7 days
Funds provided Secured Automated Clearing Home (ACH), or a direct financial institution switch Financial institution draft
Payout 24 hours after sale Similar day cost
Automotive pick-up Free pick-up No automotive pick-up
Bodily areas 183 retailer areas 235 retailer areas
Turnaround time 24 hours 24 hours
Customer support E mail, telephone On-line chat, telephone, e mail
Evaluations 4.4 1.7

Examine to Different Automotive Shopping for Web sites


Peddle logo

Get your free supply immediately by way of on-line kind or name on (855) 925 4302

$0 charges + you don’t need to pay for towing – Peddle will handle it

Receives a commission in examine throughout the decide up for any automotive (broken, junk, wrecked)


CarBrain logo

Get a suggestion inside 2 minutes and promote your broken automotive inside 24 hours

Free automobile towing and no charges to eliminating your broken automotive

The tow truck driver will arrive along with your examine (nationwide service)


Wheelzy logo

Fast automotive analysis with out the effort – promote your automotive inside 30 min

Select a handy date and time free of charge pick-up, as quickly as subsequent day

Get money in hand the identical day the Wheelzy agent picks up your automotive

Vehicles Accepted

Shift and CarMax each purchase used cars which can be in drivable situation, in addition to automobiles which can be leased. With Shift, you may promote your leased automotive in practically the identical means as every other financed automotive. Shift will consider your automotive and require a replica of your lease buyout packet.

Carmax will appraise the automotive, contact the leasing firm for a payoff quote and course of any fairness you may have. CarMax does have a listing of auto corporations that it can not buy leased automobiles from.


Neither Shift, nor CarMax cost any charges for selling your car. Each corporations supply a free analysis and quote to your automotive.

They each earn a living by reselling the automobiles they purchase from customers for revenue.

Requesting Quotes

Each Shift and CarMax supply free instantaneous quotes after you submit an internet software kind. 

Data you will want to incorporate in a Shift or CarMax software:

  • Make and mannequin of your automotive
  • Yr of producing
  • License plate or Automobile Identification Quantity

Supply Validity

When you obtain your supply from Shift and CarMax, your supply is legitimate for 7 days. You’ll be able to think about the supply inside this timeframe and both settle for or decline it.

Funds Supplied

After your automotive passes the ultimate inspection with Shift, you’ll be notified by e mail, and Shift will request your checking account info to make an ACH switch. 

Whenever you promote your automotive with CarMax, you may go away along with your cost in hand on the identical day of creating your sale. CarMax pays with a financial institution draft which should be deposited at a financial institution and may take 1-4 days to indicate up in your checking account.

Shift and CarMax each supply a trade-in choice and require you to drop off your automotive at an in-person retailer location.


With Shift, as soon as the cost has been initiated the processing time can take as much as 3-7 enterprise days, relying in your financial institution. 

With CarMax, you’ll go away with cost in hand the identical day you promote your automotive. When you obtain your financial institution draft, you may head to your native financial institution to make your withdrawal. Be sure to examine along with your financial institution to see if they’ve a selected holy coverage on deposits.

Automotive Choose-up

Shift provides automotive pick-up companies, in addition to the choice to drop your automotive off at one in all their retailer areas. It’s also possible to obtain an analysis of your automotive performed at your property by a Shift affiliate.

With CarMax, you might be required to drop off your automotive at one in all their retailer areas for analysis, and to finish a sale.

Bodily Areas

You’ll be able to ship your automotive to one in all Shift’s 183 retailer areas. 

With CarMax, you may ship your automotive to one in all their 235 physical locations throughout the US.

Turnaround Time

Each Shift and CarMax supply a really fast turnaround time to sell your car. It often takes as much as 24 hours to promote your automotive with each corporations.

Buyer Service

If in case you have any questions or issues, you may contact Shift customer support by:

  • Telephone: +1 (855) 744-1445
  • E mail:

You’ll be able to contact CarMax customer support by:

  • On-line chat
  • Telephone: (716) 243-4850
  • E mail (every retailer location has a person e mail handle)


Shift has a 4.4-star score on Trustpilot, whereas the general CarMax score is 1.7 stars on Trustpilot. Shift has a 3.3-star score on BBB, whereas CarMax has a 1.1-star score on BBB.

Clients have praised Shift for offering glorious customer support, offering honest costs for these promoting automobiles, and having a fast turnaround time. Some prospects have raised complaints about not with the ability to contact buyer assist, gross sales being delayed, and never receiving funds on time.

CarMax prospects have praised the dealership for offering a fast turnaround time, pleasant customer support, and providing good costs for automobiles. Clients have complained about CarMax altering their value provides, not disclosing damages to automobiles, and offering poor customer support.

Shift CarMax
Trustpilot Ranking 4.4 1.7
BBB Ranking 3.3 1.1

Shift & CarMax Options


Peddle Abstract

  • Buys used, broken or junk automotive nationwide
  • Get instantaneous quote on (855) 925 4302
  • Free towing inside 48 hours after supply
  • Obtain cost upon automotive assortment

Much like Shift and CarMax, Peddle provides you an instantaneous quote after you submit an internet software kind by their web site. After receiving a suggestion, you’ll have 7 days to simply accept the supply similar to with Shift and CarMax. Peddle provides to ship a Peddle consultant to select up or tow your automotive free of charge.

Like with CarMax, Peddle will hand you a examine on the identical day of the sale. Compared to Shift and CarMax, Peddle is a extra trusted car-buying firm with a 4.7-star score on Trustpilot, and a 4.7-star score on BBB.


Wheelzy Abstract

  • Wheelzy shops are open 7 days every week
  • Get supply in minutes – (855) 510-1108
  • Free towing of your automotive out of your location
  • On the spot cost by way of money or examine

Like Shift, which makes use of a proprietary algorithm, Wheelzy makes use of AI to supply an estimated worth of your automotive utilizing the data you submit utilizing the web software kind. 

Wheelzy accepts automobiles which can be damaged or thought-about to be junk, whereas CarMax and Shift settle for automobiles which can be used and in drivable situation. When you settle for a suggestion, a Wheelzy consultant will decide up or tow your automotive free of charge.

Wheelzy has a 4.8-star score on Trustpilot, and a 3-star score on BBB.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles