Sunday, March 26, 2023

Which Product Ought to You Create?

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?

Photograph by Mark Fletcher-Brown on Unsplash

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?Darren says: At this time Shayne Tilley continues our sequence on creating products for your blog by analyzing the necessary query of “what product must you create?”

It is a query I do know many ProBlogger readers are pondering as a result of I get requested it many instances.

  • “Ought to I create an eBook, a course, a membership space or one thing else?”
  • “What subject ought to I create a product round?”

When you’re asking questions like these – Shayne’s recommendation on this put up is for you.

As I did in last week’s post – I’m going to chime in with my perspective too.

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?Possibly it’s simply me, however my tackle this query is the second-biggest resolution you’ll make as a blogger. Second solely to “what ought to I weblog about?”. So in case you’ve been stressing concerning the reply – congratulations, you’re regular!

While I’ve been concerned with a whole bunch of merchandise in my profession, it’s nonetheless one thing I debate in my very own head and with these whom I work. It’s a debate effectively price having.

On this put up I’m going to share with you the method I am going by way of when answering this query, whether or not it’s in my head or with others.

This course of is a fruits of each my private experiences and my learnings from wonderful entrepreneurs akin to Darren, Matt Mickiewich, Mark Harbottle, and others you’ve in all probability by no means heard of.

This course of doesn’t assure success, however hopefully it provides you a method ahead as you reply this query your self. Simply remember that each blogger has totally different circumstances, audiences, matters, and targets – and on the finish of the day you’ll must reply the query for your self.

So let’s get began.

Not What… However Why

The very first thing we’re going to do is just not determine what we’re going to construct, however as an alternative we’re going to outline why – and it’s a two-part why.

Your Why

The primary is answering why YOU need to create this product.

What’s your motivation?

The reply will be cash and for lots of you will probably be, however it must run deeper.

The motivation for cash, and at this stage theoretical cash, will reduce as you’re working in your product at 2am on a Sunday.  Once you realise that it’s going to take twice as lengthy and value twice as a lot as you thought beginning out, there must be extra of an incentive.

I actually encourage you to look at Simon Sinek’s Golden Circle video to grasp precisely what meaning.

Let me share what I imply with a easy illustration.

Query: Why am I penning this put up on a sunny Saturday afternoon and never exterior doing one thing else?

Reply: As a result of the thought that this put up may encourage somebody to create their very own nice product in some small method which may change the trajectory of their dwell in a optimistic method endlessly, is rather more rewarding to me than something I could possibly be doing exterior.

So I write…

I need you to have the ability to in a roundabout way be capable of describe in someway your individual private why.

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?Darren says: It’s been some time since I watched that Simon Sinek video – thanks for the nudge to take action once more Shayne, it was an excellent reminder to do some self evaluation of my very own ‘why’.

A private instance: Over ten years in the past once we began the Australian ProBlogger occasion, I did so with a really clear ‘why’. I needed to encourage, encourage and equip Aussie bloggers to do wonderful issues with their blogs.

I’ve advised the story quite a few instances so gained’t rehash it right here – however my aim with the occasion was fairly single-minded and revenue was the very last thing on my thoughts. My imaginative and prescient was fairly clear and so after I started to share that dream with a couple of others, I used to be capable of rapidly talk it. I discovered that in doing so, the concept caught maintain of others.

I actually consider that understanding the ‘why’ helped us create an occasion that has grown every year. 

Realizing the why retains driving me ahead (even when it will get powerful). 

Realizing the why has helped me appeal to a core workforce collectively who work for a similar function.

Realizing the why has helped us talk what the occasion is about to attendees.

Realizing the why shapes the ‘what’ of what we truly DO on the occasion.

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?

Your Buyer’s Why

The second “why” you’ll need to assume by way of is: why would your prospects purchase your product? Ask that with supplementary questions of who’re they, and what are their issues?

And it’s time to tug out the pen and paper, or the spreadsheet.

What are the issues your readers have?

I need you to listing as lots of the issues your readers have as you probably can.

In last week’s post I shared with you the need to grasp your readers, and that is the place the advantages of that begin to play out.

Don’t leap to the answer. I repeat: don’t leap to the answer.

At this stage you’re simply researching, not creating path of motion.  We are going to get to that, I promise.

Listing all of your readers’ issues, huge and small.

For instance for a weblog about lawns (a foolish instance for illustrative functions):

My readers all have lawns, they’re all pleased with their lawns. Which isn’t a shock as that’s what I weblog about. With spring on the best way, with out some care and a spotlight, these lawns are going to get uncontrolled in a short time. Once I surveyed my readers, garden mowing was their number-one concern.

Downside:  My garden must be mown so I can nonetheless be pleased with it.

The readers of the garden lovers weblog in all probability have some others.

– I must eliminate weeds

– I must hold my garden vibrant and wholesome

– I need to have a garden, however undecided the place to start out

You must, with a bit of effort, be capable of provide you with greater than 20 issues your readers have. There’s by no means been a weblog I haven’t been capable of establish much more for.

If you find yourself occupied with issues, it’s usually straightforward to give attention to the sensible, or ‘points’ your readers have. However don’t overlook that individuals additionally prefer to be entertained (their drawback may be being bored). They like itemizing to tales and admiring creativity (their drawback may be that they lack inspiration).

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?From Darren: One of many key instructing factors in lots of the keynotes that I ship is to grow to be hyper-aware of issues (each your individual and people of others). I really consider that this consciousness of the issues of others places you within the excellent place to serve others, and create the #1 ingredient to a profitable enterprise – usefulness.

I’ve beforehand recommended 11 methods to establish reader issues in this post within the ProBlogger archives

Not solely will these strategies show you how to create product concepts but additionally they’ll show you how to provide you with weblog put up concepts too!

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?


So now we’ve obtained issues, let’s see if we will clear up them!

The subsequent step is to consider doable options which may exist for every of these issues. Let’s go together with the lawm mowing drawback.

Answer: I can mow my very own garden

Answer: I can get another person to mow my garden

Each are viable and each would clear up the issue 100%. There may be all the time a number of options to the identical drawback, you simply must assume it by way of.

We’ve solved it! Or have we?

So we’ve obtained a few options to the nice garden mowing drawback of my readers. That is basically a DIY or done-for-you.  From that, we then establish a number of the boundaries to activating the DIY answer.

Barrier: I don’t personal a garden mower

Barrier: I don’t know find out how to use a garden mower

Barrier: I’ve a garden mower, however it’s damaged

Okay, now you’re in all probability beginning to see product alternatives.  What may I do to take away these boundaries to the DIY garden mower drawback. Let’s go together with the I don’t personal a garden mower.  One other drawback!

Answer: Nicely, you possibly can purchase one!

Barrier: I don’t know which one to purchase

Barrier: I don’t know the place I should purchase one

Barrier: I don’t have any cash

Preserve going…

Downside: I don’t know which one to purchase

Answer: A information, some recommendation or coaching one find out how to purchase a garden mower.

Now we have a product thought!

So then it’s easy. Rinse and repeat.

What you could have achieved is taken the issues of your readers, drilled them down into smaller ones by understanding boundaries, after which drilling them down till now we have a slender and really particular potential answer to the issue.

I’ve on function solved my drawback with an academic final result, nevertheless some shall be action-based (for instance: one other answer may be to promote them a lawnmower), some shall be service-based (for instance: a listing of garden mowing companies) and a few shall be training- and educational-based.

Whatever the sort, they are going to be all required and valued by somebody.

Take every drawback in your listing and start to drill down to seek out options by figuring out boundaries and smaller issues till you could have a listing of product concepts.

At this stage you’ll have a protracted listing of potential merchandise. Once you truly take a look at this on paper (or spreadsheet), is it any surprise you weren’t certain which product to construct?

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?Darren says: I hope you see a number of the energy of this system. Fairly than merely making an attempt to brainstorm product concepts, what Shayne is suggesting is rather more about coming at product concepts from the attitude of your potential buyer.

Brainstorming their issues on this method is not going to solely show you how to to provide you with a product thought (it ought to in all probability show you how to provide you with a number of viable ones), however by doing this you’ll even be in a significantly better place to put in writing and launch that product additionally as you’ll have a greater understanding of what questions the product ought to reply and what is going to inspire folks to purchase it!

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?

Cull and Focus

It’s now time to cull and focus.

Now you can seize the crimson pen, or be on the prepared on the delete key, and begin working from the highest, eradicating any merchandise which are merely not doable, or not one thing you have an interest in doing.

For instance, as a blogger you’re in all probability not involved in promoting mowers straight, in order that’s gone.

You will see, in case you’ve frolicked on the above train, that you just’ll strike by way of quite a bit , if not a majority of the options. That’s okay, however don’t delete them, put them on the sometime/possibly pile as a result of when you find yourself occupied with your subsequent product your circumstances may need modified.

Let’s assume that you just’ve obtained three official product concepts. For this little garden blogger, it’s all the knowledge merchandise.

  1. Info and coaching on find out how to purchase a mower
  2. Info on find out how to hold my mower in tip-top form
  3. Info on find out how to use a garden mower successfully

Our subsequent step is to take a look at the potential and viability of every of these merchandise – we will try this a couple of methods.

What number of?

That you must decide (and a finest guess is okay) how many individuals would need these merchandise?

You gained’t promote it to all of them, however you employ it as a comparability.  We all know that solely folks wanting to purchase a mower may need coaching on find out how to purchase one, folks with a mower and other people shopping for one may need to know find out how to preserve it, in addition to find out how to use it.

So we all know, that there’s a greater marketplace for merchandise 2 and three.

How a lot?

The counterbalance to that is: what worth do folks placed on you fixing that drawback for them (thus how a lot are they prepared to pay you)?

In case you are about to purchase a mower, you’re about to spend some huge cash, so your readers may put the next worth on that.  The place as utilizing a mower is fairly straightforward to determine so not an excellent worth is placed on fixing that.

Take the market measurement and a number of it purchase the worth, and also you’ll have a complete potential worth on every of these merchandise and rank them so as.

Let’s say for our little mowing challenge it’s now

  1. Info on find out how to use a garden mower
  2. Info and coaching on find out how to purchase a mower
  3. Info on find out how to hold my mower in tip high form

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?Darren says: Feeling like you want to mow your garden but? I do!

My key recommendation on this ‘culling of concepts’ part is that doing this train the primary time is normally the toughest. By doing this work now you’ll hopefully provide you with a number of concepts that might effectively set your product creation technique for the subsequent 12 months or so.

You’ll additionally discover that by doing this course of as soon as absolutely the primary time that you just’ll discover it truly turns into extra intuitive and a pure a part of your small business. 

As you grow to be used to doing this evaluation, you’ll begin to get extra of a intestine really feel as to which kind of merchandise will work and which wont together with your viewers.

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?

Analyse the Competitors

We now know that our ‘find out how to use a garden mower product’ is viable – now it’s time to look sideways at our competitors.

For our garden mowing instance, we must always now begin trying on the merchandise that exist that train folks find out how to use a garden mower.

Be aware of these product’s options, format, advantages, price, measurement all the things you’ll be able to about them.

If there is no such thing as a competitors for the challenge, nice!  It’s unlikely, however you’ve obtained an actual alternative in your palms.

If there’s competitors for every of your product concepts, beginning at your number-one product, begin detailing why your product can be distinctive.

Merely reply the “I’d purchase my product over theirs as a result of ….“.

Certainly one of three issues will occur:

  1. You may’t outline something to differentiate your product. On this case you in all probability want to maneuver on.
  2. You will have a novel level of distinction, however it’s not a robust one.  You in all probability want to maneuver on.
  3. You’ll have a novel method to this product that individuals will love.

We’re near having a call on a product.  We now simply must outline it a bit of extra.

The one remaining merchandise in our garden transferring challenge is:

  1. Info and coaching on find out how to purchase a mower

Type and Options

The ultimate step is to outline what type and options this product can have.

With data and coaching it may be:

  • Digital (eBook, video sequence, blended course, content material)
  • Bodily (e-book, coaching handbook, dvd)
  • Face-to-face (coaching program)

Defining this half is difficult, because it’s going to come back all the way down to what your reader prefers, what you’ll be able to ship, and what may exist already out there.

Because of this it’s very a lot a query answered by the phrases ‘it relies upon’, and the reply shall be totally different for every particular person studying this text.

The Execs and Cons of eBooks, Video and Programs

I do know a number of ProBlogger readers shall be uncertain from a digital data product standpoint what method to take, so let me share my perspective on that.

 1. eBooks


  • Most cost-effective
  • Fast to market
  • Easy supply and formatting
  • No enormous expertise burdens
  • Simple to promote your self of leverage open marketplaces
  • Simple to replace
  • -On-line or offline


  • Restricted on worth
  • Some issues are exhausting to show in footage and phrases
  • Not everyone seems to be a reader
  • Very straightforward to be shared and tougher to regulate copyright smart

 2. Video or video sequence


  • Fashionable and really visible (you’ll be able to present and inform)
  • Nice for these that aren’t writers
  • Instruments lately are making manufacturing a lot simpler
  • A way more private expertise
  • On-line or off-line


  • Fulfilment overheads and technical challenges
  • Tougher to replace an preserve content material
  • Not all your readers can take care of the expertise (but)
  • You’ll want gear and software program (and knowhow) to make it stand out

 3. Programs


  • Better of each wolds – phrases, footage and movies when wanted
  • Two method communitation – Q&A’s boards and many others
  • Rising open marketplaces
  • Appears to be the best way of the long run


  • Largest preliminary setup time requirement
  • Fulfilment overheads and technical challenges
  • Tougher to replace an preserve content material
  • Not everybody can take care of the expertise (but)
  • You’ll want gear and software program (and knowhow) to make it stand out
  • Troublesome to run on autopilot (you want to be concerned ongoing).

Once more, let me be clear there is no such thing as a blanket proper or incorrect alternative with this. It’s about making a call that you’re snug with.

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?Darren says: clearly I’ve targeted most of my efforts on eBooks over the previous few years. My reasoning for doing so on the time was partly that it was probably the most achievable for me to create an eBook, but additionally that on the time (5 years in the past) I felt that it was in all probability probably the most accessible format for many of my readers at Digital Images College.

I’d advise that in case you’re creating your first product that you just don’t chunk off greater than you’ll be able to chew. Except you’ve obtained some money to splash on getting a number of assist to create your product, starting with one thing achievable might be one of the best beginning place.

Creating Products: Which Product Should You Create?

The Takeaway:

Studying by way of this put up may really feel fairly intense and maybe a bit of over-the-top for a bit of product creation challenge.

However after I put it in these easy steps I hope it doesn’t appear that method.

  1. Outline your individual motives for making a product
  2. Outline your prospects and the issues they’ve
  3. Outline options for these issues
  4. Outline your distinctive level of distinction out there
  5. Uncover if the dimensions of the market will make it well worth the funding
  6. Outline what type your product will take

See it’s not that tough!

Closing Ideas on Selecting Which Product to Create:

Just a few last ideas earlier than we transfer onto truly constructing your product (which we’ll cowl tomorrow):

The product that delivers to its promise wins, not the one with probably the most options.

You don’t must be first to market to personal it. Google wasn’t the primary search engine on the web, however it was one of the best.

When you consider in additional than simply the cash, it should carry you a lot additional.

What labored for them gained’t all the time be the factor that works for you.

Merchandise that train you find out how to create merchandise that train others find out how to create merchandise … is just not a product.

Don’t all the time assume as a blogger you want to create data merchandise. Companies and instruments will be rather more worthwhile over a long term that books eBooks and programs.

That’s it for at the moment! Subsequent week we get to construct some stuff.


This text was up to date 13 October 2022.

Need to know extra about advertising and marketing merchandise and different methods to earn cash from running a blog?

Then take a look at our Four Pillars of Blogging: Make Money Course.

Creating Products: Before You Even Think About Creating Products, Think About This

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles